Tests & reviews

Scarpa - Manta Tech GTX - Mountaineering boots tested

Praise vs. Criticism

David

11.03.2022

Superb, warm and stable boot.

I used these for a week in the Swiss Alps. They are warm but the insulation/construction breathes really well, no sweaty feet after working/walking hard.

I take a 10.5 (UK) in normal Scarpa hiking boots (Delta's etc.) and found the same size to be ideal for the Manta Tech's. I could wear a mid to heavyweight wool sock comfortably. If I needed a liner sock + heavyweight sock, I probably would have gone 1/2 up but for my needs I was just fine with a mid weight wool sock and mty normal boot size - Scarpa already run large in my experience.

They really come into their own in the snow, on ice and on surfaces where stability and support are essential and of course the stiff sole and crampon compatability adds to their functionality for the intended terrain. They maintain excellent foot and ankle support and good overal foot postion, for someone with 'weak ankles' that has a tendency to roll my ankles even walking on pavement, this is important. The lacing system is particularly good with two locking lugs at the ankle position - this ensures laces stay tight and in place.

They are a chunky boot, no doubt, but I didn't find them heavy and the actual profile makes them quite precise on challenging surfaces. I wore them all day long without any issue. This is a boot for above the snow line, for that purpose, they really really quite excellent!

Advantages
Robust
Good grip
Price / performance
Waterproof
VS

Michael

19.11.2022

Just too uncomfortable for walking

Having great reviews and a reputation as a 'classic' is not sufficient, I personally found this boot to be just too uncomfortable to wear. Sure, it takes a crampon, but your feet have to survive getting to the base of the mountain first! The problem for me is that the transition from heel strike to forefoot is just too abrupt, making for a deeply uncomfortable slapping motion each time I take a step. There is absolutely no heel rocker at all on these beautiful, but in my opinion flawed, mountaineering boots. There's going to be bargain on ebay very soon.

Advantages
Robust
Good grip
Disadvantages
Uncomfortable

What do you think about that?

You have reached the max. number of characters.

Oops! You forgot to ask your question.

Click the number of stars to complete your review of this product

Click the number of stars to complete your review of this product

What is your review for this product?
(Click stars for your review mark)
Upload image

By completing this upload you confirm our Terms of Use

This is what customers from around the world say:

Roger
07.05.2021

75% have found the reviews
by Roger helpful

  • Advantages
    Robust
Thomas
14.07.2024

  • Advantages
    Good grip
    Robust
    Waterproof