Tests & reviews

Edelrid - Commander Pants - Softshell pants tested

What do you think about that?

Click the number of stars to complete your review of this product

Click the number of stars to complete your review of this product

What is your review for this product?

Upload image

By completing this upload you confirm our Terms of Use

This is what other customers say:
Thomas's profile picture
| Milford
Great trousers

Great trousers. Well made. Good fit. I liked the cut of the climbing pant, so I tried these softshells and love them too. I was surprised to see another reviewer suggest they have very wide hips, I wouldn't say so at all.

Only negative is a weirdly positioned pocket on the back of the thigh. I can't see myself ever using that pocket, but that's not a big deal.

  • Advantages
    Waterproof
    Price/performance
    Windproof
    Breathable
    Robust
    Good cut
    Lightweight
  • Disadvantages
    Weirdly positioned pocket
's profile picture

Oops! You forgot about your comment

james's profile picture
| Glasgow
Great pants for climbing, bouldering, and hiking!

Great stretch, freedom of movement and water resistance. Four very usable zipped pockets, the pocket on the back of the leg (at the thigh) is great for a phone, wallet or energy bar and sits nicely out of the way of a harness and being smacked off the rock or wall. My only complaint is the cut. These pants have a very generous cut in the hips (which actually bulge out from the waistband down to the top of the thigh). I honestly thought I'd been sent the women's version when I opened the package, they looked a bit like jodphurs. The thing is, there's absolutely no need for them to be cut this way as the material and stretch inserts allow complete freedom of movement. I had them professionally altered and now they are perfect. If you can be bothered having them altered, or have hips like a woman from a classical painting, I totally recommend them as they are great to climb in and breathe really well. At the price I paid, they still worked out to be good value even with the tailors fee.

  • Advantages
    Robust
    Breathable
    Price/performance
    Good details
    Lightweight
  • Disadvantages
    Badly cut
's profile picture

Oops! You forgot about your comment

This is what customers from around the world say:
David's profile picture
| RIORGES

  • Advantages
    Waterproof
    Windproof
    Price/performance
    Robust
  • Disadvantages
    Badly cut
Tim's profile picture
| Helmond

  • Advantages
    Good cut
    Robust
Jochen's profile picture
| Karlsruhe

85% have found the reviews
by Jochen helpful

  • Advantages
    Robust
    Breathable
    Good cut
    Price/performance
Bastian's profile picture
| Hamburg

100% have found the reviews
by Bastian helpful

  • Advantages
    Price/performance
    Breathable
  • Disadvantages
    Badly cut
Stefan's profile picture
| Konstanz

73% have found the reviews
by Stefan helpful

  • Advantages
    Price/performance
    Waterproof
    Breathable
    Good details
    Windproof
    Robust
    Lightweight
    Good cut
Marco's profile picture
| Hermannsburg

  • Advantages
    Breathable
    Windproof
    Price/performance
Peter's profile picture
| Bexbach

  • Advantages
    Windproof
    Good cut
    Price/performance
    Robust
Markus's profile picture
| Chemnitz

41% have found the reviews
by Markus helpful

  • Advantages
    Robust
    Price/performance
Maximilian's profile picture
| Gerolzhofen

100% have found the reviews
by Maximilian helpful

  • Advantages
    Price/performance
Thomas's profile picture
| Odenthal

77% have found the reviews
by Thomas helpful

  • Disadvantages
    Badly cut
Carsten's profile picture
| Bad Berleburg

  • Advantages
    Robust
    Good details
  • Disadvantages
    Badly cut
Moritz's profile picture
| Dachsberg

85% have found the reviews
by Moritz helpful

  • Advantages
    Robust
    Price/performance
£ 5 now
For your next order
No thank you.